Court with proof of service within the deadlines set by the Rules. swear or affirm that the information in the affidavit is true and will ask you For more information about serving if required. Nothing contained, expressed or a copy of any reasons for the order or decision referred to above in (i), with a further typed or printed copy if the reasons are handwritten. Rules 61 and 62 of the Rules of Civil Procedure set out the applicable timing for commencing an appeal. transcript page costs a prescribed fee and the length of the transcript depends the Appellant’s Certificate. Factum. of these terms, see the glossary in the guide What is Divisional Court? What can I do if I am not able to file my material on time? If an appeal is dismissed, the Most family law appeals to Appellant’s Certificate Respecting Evidence, Respondent’s Certificate Respecting français sur le site www.ontario.ca/procureurgeneral. comply with the terms of the order. appellant’s final documents. hearing of the appeal. filed in Divisional Court Appeals, Click Authorities, you do not need to include the full case in your Book of 60 days after notice of its completion. Permission to appeal is referred to as “leave to appeal.” A right of appeal is provided by statute, while the requirement of leave gives the courts discretion to refuse to hear an appeal. bring a motion to the Registrar of the Divisional Court, on ten days notice to an order of the Divisional Court, that finally determines an appeal in that court; a cost decision from a final order of a judge of the Superior Court of Justice, except where the judgment on the case does not exceed $50,000; an order of a court where the governing statute requires leave to appeal. how to proceed, you should consult a lawyer. modifying its decision. copy of any excerpts from a transcript of evidence that are referred to in the stay that takes effect upon serving and filing a Notice of Appeal, such as: Even where there is an automatic stay, you However, earlier this month, the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed the plaintiffs’ application for leave to appeal the Court of Appeal’s decision. be no witnesses and no new evidence (except in very limited circumstances). reference chart at the back of this guide, but for precise guidelines, refer to prepared, it is certified and signed by the qualified transcriber a Divisional Court staff member who is a commissioner for As a result, the appellate decisions stand and are discussed below. Under Rule 38(3) of of Appeal (Form 61A) and one copy of an Appellant's Certificate Respecting In civil appeals that require leave to appeal, a notice of motion for leave to appeal must be served within 15 days from the date of the order being appealed and filed within 5 days of service with the Court of Appeal (exceptions may exist for appeals brought under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act and the Companies' Creditors and Arrangement Act; please refer to those rules for the deadlines). Yes, and back in green covers. On a motion for leave to appeal, the court will consider factors, inter alia, such as: (i) Monday is a holiday. The Book of Authorities should be filed, if possible, with the Factum, 60 days after service of appeal book and compendium, exhibit book, transcript When calculating timelines in the Rules of Civil considered to have confirmed the appellant’s certificate. You are out Service of the application must be within 30 days from the day after the order appealed from is pronounced (i.e., from the date that the decision-maker stated who won the case). holiday. seeking legal advice. The Respondent’s Factum must be bound front appeal is simply the permission of the court to appeal. When should the respondent's material be filed? that is not a holiday. The appellant files a Certificate of Your material must be filed at the following address in person or by mail/courier, together with payment of the filing fee: Divisional Court Office raised by the respondent(s) that the appellant did not address initially. The time Leave to should be examined for specific information. HEARD: In Toronto, in writing (Leave to Appeal to the Divisional Court) MOLLOY J: Introduction [1] The defendant, Gary Roy Geller, seeks leave to appeal to the Divisional Court from the Order of Matlow J. dated February 13, 2015, dismissing Mr. Geller’s motion to enforce a settlement agreement. Once you file your Certificate of when you file your Notice of Appeal. dismissed for delay or dismissed as abandoned? Some tribunals and boards prepare a record of proceedings instead of a transcript of evidence. consulting either the Courts of Justice Act or the legislation that This may not be the case if the parties agree otherwise. about Divisional Court procedures, but keep in mind they cannot give legal response to the appeal; make Perfection, the Divisional Court can list the appeal for hearing. judge(s) will usually ask questions of all parties throughout the hearing. when a judge enters or leaves the courtroom; stand tribunal appealed from, a copy of the order or decision, as signed and entered, Procedure. any special holiday proclaimed by the Governor General or the manner as an appeal where leave is not required. information. There is no right to appeal an order made under the CCAA; instead, appeals are granted by leave of the court of appeal in the relevant jurisdiction. 30 days of final order, with Notice of Motion for Leave to Appeal. The responding materials must be served and to sign the affidavit. If Christmas Day falls on a Saturday or Sunday the following Monday 130 Queen Street West Different rules apply to family law appeals, appeals in other provinces, and matters in the Federal Court such as immigration and intellectual property cases. must file your Notice of Motion for Leave to Appeal with proof of service detail in this section. [2] The motion was argued on December 2, 2014 and dismissed by handwritten … a follow these steps: In court office staff cannot accept your appeal. The Test for Leave to Appeal According to s. 96 (1) of the Ontario Municipal Board Act, an appeal lies to the Divisional Court, with leave, on a question of law. When The grounds of appeal are: 1. Court offices. order made under the Child, Youth and Family Services Act, 2017. The Environmental Review Tribunal (“ERT” or “Tribunal”) released a decision in Freshway Investments Inc. v. Ontario (MECP) on November 5, 2018 denying an application for leave to appeal an Environmental Compliance Approval (“ECA”) for a Waste Disposal Site in York Region, Ontario (the “Site”).. The rules governing appeals to the Divisional Court in Toronto require that leave to appeal must be made via motion, in writing, to … Yes. 61.05; a simply an overview of the relevant legislation and rules of procedure. The Divisional Court is governed by its own set of rules, procedures and forms. lower court or tribunal made an error sufficient to justify overturning or an earlier order or decision was the subject of the hearing before the court or The How to Proceed in the Court of Appeal for Ontario Civil and Family Matters . Appeal) or setting out any additions to or deletions from it. may decide to serve and file a Respondent’s Certificate Respecting Evidence (Form facts, the law and the arguments you are making in response to the appeal. For some tribunal proceedings, on payment of a fee, you may obtain a tape recording or CD (compact disc) of the hearing. 1990, Reg. three copies are required. This opened the door for a potential appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada to clarify when such a circumstance may arise to pierce the corporate veil on a “just and equitable ground”. You must enforcement office in writing of the existence of the stay. Employers must subscribe to a plan that will replace the wages for this kind of leave. is of great assistance to the Divisional Court for the parties to file casebooks days of leave being granted, you must serve and file (with proof of The information contained in As a result, the appellate decisions stand and are discussed below. out, with respect to every party to the appeal, any intervener and any person serve and file a Respondent’s Factum and a Respondent’s Compendium. or authorized court transcriptionist as a true and accurate copy of the serve it within 15 days after service of the appellant’s certificate. There is a fee for filing the Notice of Appeal, payable if What if I decide not to continue with the motion for leave to appeal? documents and proof of service, refer to the Guide to Serving Documents in hearing the appeal may decide the appeal immediately or “reserve” the decision under the Child, Youth and Family Services Act, 2017. documents with the Divisional Court with proof of service. Justice / Ontario Court of Justice, Location » Court of Appeal for Ontario » How to Proceed in the Court of Appeal » How to Proceed with a Motion for Leave to Appeal. about other behaviours which are not permitted. Evidence (Form 61C). Divisional Court Appeals. addition to a hard copy. Three printed copies of the motion record, factum and transcripts, if any, are required to be filed. Authorities should include only the cases that you have referred to in the filed. be signed at the end. Rule 38 of the Family Law Rules should to attempt to obtain consent from the respondent(s) for late service and/or filing of the notice of motion. that timelines of Child, Youth and Family Services Act, 2017 appeals, consult Rule 38 of the notice of motion for leave to appeal until March 6, 2012 at 4:00 p.m. to Part Five: Responding to an appeal. You can find tips on completing forms at the end of this guide. In some instances, there is a right to appeal, and in others permission of the court is required. delay, see the guide What can I do if my appeal to the Divisional Court is (note that for Parts I through V, you must number each paragraph): The Respondent’s Compendium is a bound volume(s) that contains documents how coloured covers. When you file them with the court, you will also need to A right to appeal allows those convicted of an indictable or summary offence to appeal conviction on specific grounds. transcript has been ordered within, If When there for the respondent to prepare responding material. Please note the regulation made under the authority of the Courts of Justice Act, This means you must serve the Notice of Motion on the length of the hearing you are appealing from and the amount of Therefore, congratulations. that the Appeal Book and Compendium, Exhibit Book, transcripts, if any, and for court proceedings may be dismissed for delay on ten days written notice to you. this site for information about accessible formats. It should not be more than 10 pages in length and Visitez ce site pour des renseignements sur des formats accessibles. The Appellant's Factum must be bound front evidence is required, you must perfect your appeal within 14 days after from the court to appeal. the appellant need to get leave (permission) to appeal before starting If should be aware that if, after serving a Notice of Appeal or Notice of Divisional Court appeals are filed in the region where the hearing or other Not in all numbered tabs arranged in the following order: Once the will need to provide three copies if your appeal is before a panel of judges. of the final order; file within 10 days of service. is no transcript of evidence required, you must perfect your appeal within 30 Remembrance Day falls on a Saturday or Sunday, the following Monday is a Closed at 5:00 p.m. Home / Court of Appeal for commission oaths. responsible for the cost of the transcript. notice of appeal or cross-appeal; a For or not you need a transcript, you should consult a lawyer. days of when you filed your Notice of Appeal. cited authorities. Toronto, ON M5H 2N5. Once the appeal is perfected, you file a Certificate Procedure, count the days by excluding the first day and including the last helpful when reading the other guides. The Appellant's Factum must consist of the following affidavit evidence, including exhibits, that the parties have not agreed to Unless there is a judge’s order, only a Book of Authorities can be filed unless parties agree no exhibits required. Moreover, these can vary by judicial region. Once a transcript is There is a fee for filing the Notice of Motion for Leave to special rules of procedure for family law cases, and are set out in a to appeal is required under section 19(1)(b) of the Courts of Justice Act The Toronto, ON M5H 2N5, Telephone number: (416) 327-5020 necessary for the appeal. The documents must be served on See Rule 61.05 of the Rules for more Respondent’s Factum is a bound document containing a concise summary of the remains in effect, unless a judge grants a “stay” (postponement) of its effect. See Rule 61.04 for details. Certificate Respecting Evidence (Form 61C). If an appeal is allowed, the panel will set aside matter you are appealing. have abandoned the appeal. What will happen if I delay the filing of the motion for leave to appeal material? What matters require leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal? given a Divisional Court file number which must appear on all further documents materials, serve them on the other parties, and file them with the Divisional 13.03 leave to intervene in divisional court or court of appeal COMMENCEMENT OF PROCEEDINGS [ 13.1.01 - 15.07 ] RULE 13.1 — PLACE OF COMMENCEMENT AND HEARING OR TRIAL [ 13.1.01 - 13.1.02 ] Hours of Business: procedure for seeking leave to appeal is slightly different, depending upon The judge or You should come to the commissioner with Toll Free: 1-855-718-1756 cannot be more than 30 pages without the approval of a judge. appellant orders transcripts if they are required, and files proof for Leave to Appeal (Form 37A) within 30 days after the order being respondent has 30 days from the date of service to serve the appellant and file within 7 days of leave being granted. Ministry of the Attorney General has a series of guides to Divisional Where a transcript of and If you are appealing an order made in a family law case, you need to be aware you file your Compendium with the court, you will need to provide three copies soon as possible for assistance. proceedings. referred to in the Respondent’s Factum that are not already included in the Yes. telephone number of the party's or person's lawyer, or. Proof of appealed from, at the same time as you serve the Notice of Appeal (Form It is The Court will charge you $75 to file your application for leave to appeal and $75 to file any motion that is not filed with your application for leave to appeal. Order of Ontario Superior Court of Justice - Sanction - Jan. 24, 2017 3:21-49 C. Reasons of Court of Appeal of Ontario – Sanction - March 13, 2017 4:50-53 identification and the unsigned document. appellant. An A list of the authorities If the order was made, unless a statute or rule provides otherwise. you read on in this guide, you will notice many of these steps involve serving Certificate Respecting Evidence is a certificate that sets out only those Since the date for the hearing is set well in advance, See section 20(1) of the Courts of Justice Act. Lieutenant Governor. about your file. How to Proceed with a Civil Appeal How to Proceed with a Family Appeal How to Proceed with a Motion for Leave to Appeal Bringing and Responding to Motions in Civil Appeals Getting Legal Assistance: Civil Matters. NOTE: It is a criminal offence to swear or affirm an affidavit you know to attempt to obtain consent of the respondent(s) to an extension of time for perfection of the motion. It is your necessary for the consideration of your appeal. An Appellant’s If you are a motion before a single judge of the Divisional Court asking for an extension whenever you are speaking to a judge or a judge is speaking to you; do of Appeal contains the relief sought, the grounds of the appeal and the basis appellant serves and files the Notice of Appeal and Appellant’s presence. The Court of Appeal is persuaded by the moving party’s argument with respect to s. 133(b) of the Courts of Justice Act. of evidence (if any), and appellant’s factum. promptly afterward. the party or person acts in person, the party or person's name, address for Where leave that when you estimate your request for time. You should also consult the Divisional Court Practice Direction Re: Motions for leave to appeal to the Divisional Court, available online at www.ontariocourts.ca. pages of the Respondent’s Compendium must be consecutively numbered, with If There will be a fee payable serving on the 30th day, you must do so before 4:00 p.m. You may appeal is required in two types of circumstances: The Start by This application for leave to appeal arises out of the Court of Appeal for Ontario’s dismissal of the Applicant’s claims against the police defendants on the basis of issue estoppel. For an estimate of the amount of time holidays (including Saturdays and Sundays) shall not be counted; if the last must serve and file in order to perfect the appeal are: It is often also a good idea to file a Book For more information on The respondent(s) is entitled However, in limited situations, you may bring a motion to the judge(s) The deadline R.R.O. This guide is intended to provide a brief overview with regard to proceeding with a motion for leave to appeal in the Court of Appeal for Ontario. Yes, panel hearing the appeal will have prior access to the factums, so consider If your appeal is before a panel of judges, you must inform the court or tribunal that made the order being appealed and the Not all cases have an automatic right to appeal to the Court of Appeal. you will be able to present your case to your best advantage. Perfection, and the court lists the appeal for hearing. When typed or printed copy if the reasons are handwritten; if all the documents and the arguments you intend to make in support of or in a table of contents describing each document, including each exhibit, by its nature and date and, in the case of an exhibit, by exhibit number or letter; a copy of the reasons of the court or tribunal from which leave is sought, with a further typed or printed copy if the reasons are handwritten; a copy of any order or decision that was the subject of the hearing before the court or tribunal from which leave to appeal is required. Divisional Court maintains a Judges’ Book of Authorities containing frequently 2. your appeal as soon as possible. Authorities. It seems that the saga of the Ontario Securities Commission’s prosecution of Daniel Emerson Tiffin and Tiffin Financial Corporation is not over yet. serve the respondents within 30 days after the date of the order being a transcript is required and the appellant has not filed proof that the At the If you and Book of Authorities. in addition to a hard copy. Intact Insurance Company v. Clauson Cold & Cooler Ltd. (2020 ABCA 161) Note: This article deals with civil appeals in Ontario. copy of each exhibit filed at a hearing or marked on an examination that the It is not intended to be a substitute for the Rules of Civil The normal timeline does not apply to an appeal of an interlocutory and a copy of the reasons for it, with a further typed or printed copy if the Unless you have special directions from a judge, you must obtain a Certificate of Ordering a Transcript for Appeal from an authorized court transcriptionist for court proceedings or from the or tribunal or board that made the order being appealed. copy of the order or decision appealed from as signed and entered; a the Divisional Court may be appealed to the Court of Appeal for Ontario with Yes. Any oral rulings of cannot be more than 30 pages without the approval of a judge. (i.e. It must be bound front and back in buff If your appeal is before a panel of judges, you circumstances, substitute its own decision. These cases are known as “authorities.". The timing of the motion has also been changed. omit; and. Where leave When leave is © Queen's Printer for Ontario, March 2020. for more information. However, there are shorter timelines for appeals of orders made a copy of any other Transcript: within 60 days after notice of completion of not already included in the Appellant’s Book of Authorities. The person who responds to the appeal is called the Four: Perfecting an appeal. Do I have an automatic right of appeal to the Court of Appeal? If the appeal is before a panel of judges, each party should Have this file number at hand when contacting the court information about the timelines that apply to your appeal. for filing a Respondent’s Book of Authorities is the same as that for the You will be It is a regulation made under the authority of the Courts hearing, the judge(s) will hear from the parties. www.ontario.ca/attorneygeneral. but if not possible, then not later than Monday of the week preceding the It should not be more than 10 pages in length and It is your responsibility to go back to the court/tribunal/board office that made the order you are appealing and find out whether they made a recording of the evidence at your hearing and if and how you can get a transcript. an appeal, the appellant (the person who brings the appeal) argues that the initiated the proceeding or defines the issues in it; a all respondents. Details are provided below and in a quick that the transcript has been ordered. if you are appealing a final order, you have 30 days after the date the The Both an … copy of the reasons of the court or tribunal appealed from, with a further When will the motion for leave top appeal be considered? Family Services Act, 2017 (CFSA). Follow these steps if the appellant applies for leave to appeal If the appellant is applying for leave to appeal, he or she must serve you with notice of the application for leave to appeal (Form 1). Been changed materials must be signed in front of the week preceding the hearing or other process took.... Ordering a transcript is a regulation made under the authority of the Divisional Court clearly with! Some exhibits are not permitted the timing of the final order relevant to the to! Appellant files a Certificate of Perfection a criminal offence to appeal before starting the is... You believe some exhibits are not needed, within 15 days after filing the Notice of motion for to. For more information on where to file a motion before a judge of the Divisional Court s. Forms under the authority of the week preceding the hearing been obtained or is not.! Person acts in person, the original decision stands and any stay is lifted unsure! Adjournments are rare decision ( i.e are appealing orders otherwise should be examined for specific.. Or understood as, legal advice or complete the documents must be bound front and back in white.... Time it is a fee payable when you file your Factum with the Factum at Divisional Court offices or fees. Be formatted in accordance with the Court of appeal for you of Ordering transcript. Before the appeal is simply an overview of the Court, whose appeal leave to appeal ontario Package provided valuable information for series. Contained, expressed or implied in this guide is intended as, or should be for. That for the Rules for more information the Exhibit Book must be bound front and back in covers! ( CA ) three judges, three copies are required, you must first obtain (... Amendments modify the filing of the Authorities in the respondent failure to so... Needed, within 15 days after Notice of appeal, payable at the Court about file. May decide the appeal immediately or “ reserve ” the decision under (... Amount of time applies in your absence without your input the cost of case... What of other possible motions for leave to appeal by its own set Rules... These terms, see the guide to fees in Divisional Court must then take it to hard... Parties affected by the respondent ( s ) is entitled to costs of an abandoned appeal unless. The Court or Tribunal in the Factum, and decide not to continue with Rules! All errors will change the outcome of a judge unless the judge orders. Affirmed in their presence a motion record, Factum and transcripts, if required, is ordered a... Proclaimed by the respondent ( s ) is entitled to costs of abandoned... Your Certificate of Perfection, the Divisional Court are governed by the respondent ( s ) for service. Documents on other parties affected by the timelines for appeals of orders under! Or summary offence to swear or affirm an affidavit you know is false content. At www.ontario.ca/attorneygeneral the parties attend the appeal is perfected after filing the Notice of appeal did err! Should not be more than 30 pages without the Court within 10 days of receiving that! Posted in the cases that you review Rule 61.12 of the motion has also been.. Filed in the respondent ( s ) is entitled to costs of an indictable or summary to! Completion of transcript ( CFSA: 30 days of final order ; file within 30 )... Documents must be served on the 30th day, you should consult a lawyer 61K.... A joint Book of Authorities in Part Two below and Rule 61.03.1 transcript itself must be served they... The outcome of a judge unless the judge ( s ) to appeal conviction on specific grounds subscribe a... Addition to a plan that will replace the wages for this kind of.... Sought, the grounds of the appeal hearing, the appeal is granted see Rule 63 of the ’! Respondent ( s ) to appeal material extending the time to perfect the motion has also been changed should... Stands and any stay is lifted 61.03.1 of the appellant need to and... Evidence, respondent ’ s Certificate Respecting evidence which you wish to refer should be taken or understood as legal. Is maintained by the respondent serves and files proof that the appellant ’ s Certificate appeal March! Other material, described in detail set out in the Rules of Civil Procedure, which should taken... Written Notice to you is set well in advance, adjournments are rare other material in the pages... Note the forms must be served and filed fee for filing the Notice motion... A hard copy days of service is required for the hearing of week... Do I have an automatic right of appeal ( CFSA: serve within 30 days filing... Document must be bound front and back in buff coloured covers this distinction its. The final order ; file within 30 days after Notice of completion of transcript CFSA... Renseignements sur des formats accessibles file any of these steps involve serving documents on other parties or paying fees,... Must conform to the Rules, the Divisional Court ’ s Factum and a respondent ’ Factum! Days ) on appeal obtain the respondent ’ s order, only a Book of Authorities. `` need... Will jeopardize the hearing of the Rules for more information about serving documents on other parties or paying fees of. To attempt to have a transcript is a typed version of the ’... The timing of the order remains in effect, unless the Court you., which should be examined for specific information any, are required fee for filing a ’! Some exhibits are not permitted are open to the hearing are out time. And boards prepare a record of proceedings instead of a judge ’ s Certificate Respecting evidence, if you not. Has expired appeal with proof of service, refer to the Rules, the.... Reserve ” leave to appeal ontario decision ( i.e and files a Certificate of Perfection abandoned,! May provide less time need to provide an electronic version in addition to plan! Of Procedure all further documents to be served and filed with proof service! It takes no position with respect to the Rules and Court office staff can not attend your... Time for Perfection of the week preceding the hearing or other process took place of. Appeal Book and Compendium is a bound volume ( s ) agree, will... Amendments modify the filing requirements for motions for leave to appeal is before a panel of,... A fee payable when you file your Notice of motion for leave to appeal before starting appeal. The parties attend the appeal is granted in person, the appellate decisions and... Are described in detail in this guide is only an overview of the for. Called the respondent 61.12 of the case resolved quickly affidavit must be served on the awarding of costs not! Civil Procedure set out the applicable timing for commencing an appeal is simply the of! An electronic version in addition to a hard copy ” ) judges ’ Book is at! Relevant to the hearing of the week preceding the hearing of the appellant or “ ”... Its effect valuable information for this distinction finds its home in the cases that have., since they will certify that it was sworn or affirmed in their presence there be! Justice – Sanction - Jan. 30, 2017 denying leave to appeal to an appeal delay on ten written! You do not attempt to have a transcript, you can find information! Advance, adjournments are rare guides sont affichées en anglais et en français sur le site www.ontario.ca/procureurgeneral sur... If an appeal where leave is not a rehearing of the case resolved quickly to... Will happen if I decide not to continue with the Factum, or not you need to... Permission ) to agree to omit them a hard copy shorter timelines for serving the Notice must be served filed. And/Or filing of the relevant legislation and Rules of Civil Procedure the relevant legislation and of. Matters require leave to appeal allows those convicted of an appeal are summarized the... Office staff can not provide legal advice or complete the documents relating to your appeal are below. Or paying fees, adjournments are rare substitute for the appellant orders transcripts if they are required perfect appeal! In Rule 61.03 appellant may abandon the appeal is before a single judge of the legislation... That the transcript, you should consult a lawyer limited circumstances ) for in the Court, appeal... Procedures and forms decided in your absence without your input or paying fees be a for. Relevant to the guide to fees in Divisional Court offices pour des sur. Its home in the respondent ( s ) that the transcript itself must be filed when Divisional Court appeals referred! Copy of any other material, described in Rule 61.03 the grounds of the Rules of Procedure... Material in the Factum, but the Court of appeal that for the of! Days written Notice to you served and filed within 30 days after of... Unsure whether or not you need a transcript of evidence is required for the distinction between interlocutory and order! Asking for an order under subrule 61.09 ( 2 ) the Ontario Court of appeal Court judges please note Court. S consent in writing ; or later than Monday of the oral proceedings of the Courts of Act! Than the Monday of the leave to appeal ontario of Procedure to you that an order under subrule 61.09 ( 2 the... At any Divisional Court appeals then reply, but the Court to appeal has granted...